Skip to main content
← Back to blog

Lead and cadmium in chocolate

Canopy's lab results for lead and cadmium in chocolate products, and how California's chocolate Prop 65 warning rules work.

CanopyNov 20, 2026 · 6 min read
Lead and cadmium in chocolate

Last updated November 2026. We'll add results here as we test more chocolate products.

Chocolate is one of the best-known food sources of lead and cadmium. Cadmium comes up from the soil into the cacao tree, and lead mostly lands on the beans after harvest, while they ferment and dry. Testing by Consumer Reports, academic researchers and advocacy groups has found both metals in most dark chocolate products sold in the US (Consumer Reports, 2022 and 2023; Hands et al., Frontiers in Nutrition, 2024).

So far we've tested two chocolate products: a Hershey's milk chocolate snack-size bar and Ghirardelli Premium Baking Cocoa. Each was a single package bought at a Northern California store in October 2026. Our qualified laboratory partner ran a four-metal panel by ICP-MS, a standard method for low-level heavy metal detection in food. Here's how much lead and cadmium one serving contains, compared with FDA's guidance for a 50 lb child.

Lead

FDA's interim reference level for lead is 2.2 µg a day for children (FDA, Closer to Zero). It's a fixed daily amount, so it doesn't change with body weight.

ProductPurchasedServingLead per serving% of FDA's level for a child
Ghirardelli Premium Baking CocoaOct 20261 tbsp (about 6 g)0.828 µg38%
Hershey's Milk Chocolate, snack sizeOct 20262 bars (26 g)0.364 µg17%

FDA's level is meant to cover all the lead a child gets from food in a day, from every source. A child who has one tablespoon of this cocoa every day, in hot cocoa or oatmeal for example, would use about 38% of that daily level on cocoa alone.

Cadmium

FDA's toxicological reference value for cadmium is 0.21 to 0.36 µg per kg of body weight per day (FDA, Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology, 2023). At the low end of that range, a 50 lb child's level is about 4.8 µg a day.

ProductPurchasedServingCadmium per serving% of FDA's level for a 50 lb child
Ghirardelli Premium Baking CocoaOct 20261 tbsp (about 6 g)1.12 µg24%
Hershey's Milk Chocolate, snack sizeOct 20262 bars (26 g)1.64 µg34%

The cocoa has about 10 times the lead concentration of the bar. But a serving of cocoa is a tablespoon, about 6 g, while a serving of the bar is 26 g, so the cocoa carries only about twice the bar's lead per serving and less of its cadmium. How much you eat is what really matters.

Why neither has a Prop 65 warning

When we saw the lab results, we wondered why neither product carried a Prop 65 warning. A tablespoon of the cocoa has more lead than Prop 65's usual daily limit. The answer is that chocolate has its own rules.

For most foods, California's Prop 65 requires a warning when a day's serving exposes you to more than 0.5 µg of lead or 4.1 µg of cadmium (OEHHA, Title 27 §25805). Chocolate is measured differently. Between 2014 and 2017, the nonprofit As You Sow tested hundreds of chocolate products and sent Prop 65 notices to more than 20 chocolate companies. Because the metals are hard to remove from cacao entirely, a California court approved a settlement in 2018 that replaced the per-serving test with concentration limits based on cacao percentage. The settlement also funded an expert study of where the metals come from and how to reduce them. It now covers more than 30 companies, including Hershey and Lindt, Ghirardelli's parent company. A 2023 change added small yearly cuts to the lead limits (As You Sow v. Trader Joe's Co., San Francisco Superior Court CGC-15-548791, consent judgment as modified November 2023, Section 6.2).

Cacao contentLead limit (ppm)Cadmium limit (ppm)
Up to 65%0.0600.320
Over 65% and up to 95%0.0950.400
Over 95%0.1950.800

The lead limits drop by another 0.005 ppm on February 14, 2027.

Here's how our results compare with those limits:

ProductCacao tierLead, % of tier limitCadmium, % of tier limit
Ghirardelli Premium Baking CocoaOver 95%71%23%
Hershey's Milk Chocolate, snack sizeUp to 65%23%20%

These chocolate limits apply only to companies in the settlement, mostly large manufacturers and ingredient suppliers. Other companies had a short window in 2018 to join. The limits also carry over into other foods made with cocoa. When a brownie mix, hot cocoa mix or chocolate cereal uses cocoa from a company in the settlement, the lead and cadmium from that cocoa is judged against these chocolate limits instead of the general per-serving levels (consent judgment, Section 12.4). Chocolate makers outside the settlement, including many small craft brands, are held to the general per-serving levels, so their products are much more likely to need a warning, and some add one as a precaution. A Prop 65 warning on chocolate tells you more about which rules a company follows than about how much lead or cadmium is in it. A craft bar with a warning could have less per serving than a big-brand bar without one.

Test the chocolate you buy

Want to know what's in the chocolate you eat? Request a test on any product and send it to everyone you know who eats the same one. The test runs once enough of you have chipped in.

Ready to pool in? Open tests are waiting for backers right now.

Browse open tests →

More from the blog

All posts →